” No is Yes“
NO– Pronunciation [noh]
Definition: Nay; not; not at all; not in any respect or degree; a word expressing negation, denial, or refusal. Before or after another negative, no is emphatic.
Practical definition– Ya; yes; yes definitely; Why not?; a word implying affirmation, challenging; Dar gaya? No is evasive.
God asked Adam and Eve ‘not to’ eat the apple, did they not?;Lakshman asked Sita ‘not to’ cross the laxman rekha, did she not?;
Zeus asked Pandora ‘not to’ open the Jar/box, did she not?
So, it has happened in the past and happens in the present. Harry Potter and the Gang very well know the pros and cons of entering the chamber of secrets, but the curious brains cannot take no for an option.
The board ‘No Noise please’ literally means- Silence please, practically means- stop here, giggle, be loud, discuss and leave; just as a ‘do not litter’ sign implies- throw the last night’s chilli paneer, the bread wrapper and the waste paper no where else but here.
By all the ‘No smoking’ signs on campuses or other public transports we mean you should technically not smoke, but then, we are a free country and we could not care less. And by now, we have seen n’ number of donkeys peeing at the walls painted “yahan peshab kerna mana hai” or to put it right “dekho gadha peshab ker reha hai” .
The logic is simple, by telling us ‘what not to do’ you have challenged us to do it.
It is like questioning our ‘ego’ which, is waiting for the thrill of defying rules. This is inherent in our culture, in our sub-conscious, we know that we should always atleast try what is otherwise prohibited. When I say, part of our culture, it does not only mean culture in the present day and time. Culture, as it signifies, is ever flowing and hence this nature of affirming to the negative is recorded in our texts and myths since forever.
The meteorological department warns the fishermen of an impending peril to ‘not to’ enter the waters. But the fact that they might get a better catch in free waters leads them to take the risk. At times, defying sanctity of these two letters means taking risk, to face a battle or major consequence.
Whenever you try to warn some one on why the person should not plunge into something, in most cases, it backfires. The person who is warned usually assumes there has to be some concealed motive behind the warning. After all, to trust is considered to be weak and gullible.
You see a little boy in school getting bullied by a strong nasty kid. He comes and takes his pencil away. A group of onlookers aggravate the situation just by their remark “can’t you face him? Dar gaya be”. This negation ‘Can’t’ here questions the very masculinity of the kid and begins the reason for never saying ‘no’.
No symbolises defeat, cowardliness and worthlessness.
The idea has been governing us at every field. No as a yes, guides us in our personal lives, professional lives and social lives. In love life this results in the making of loverboys, stalkers and aashiqs. A girl when says NO has to mean Yes.
The love quotient becomes stronger if it begins with a no. The persuasion increases and reaches new levels till the girl is scared enough to fall in love. But never can a ‘no’ mean a ‘no’. That is a golden rule exploited enough by cinematic medium as well.
The societal value system is such that it encourages us to not follow the ‘no’.
Take for example, a traditional lunch or preetibhoj where the art of courtesy or manwaar is at play. The guests when eating are given due respect, every effort is made to ensure that they are well fed. In other words they have ‘over-eaten’. When you say ‘no’ for a meethai or anything there will be four other people telling you “Arrey take one more. Aise kaise.” So the expression has never meant to us what it should actually mean.
Our ‘on the road’ behaviour speaks for its self. The sign says ‘no parking’ and there will be a long line of cars right in front of it. We won’t learn a lesson till it is towed away or perhaps not even after that. I remember this friend who holds a record on ‘not’ following the red light rules. He prides himself on jumping redlight a 100 times. This is the thrill that comes out with the sheer ‘negation’ of the ‘negative’.
When grown ups get into an altercation about which they cannot find a logical argument to prove their point. We often come across “humein naa sunney ki aadat nahin hai”- “we do not accept no as an answer.”
Not only is it difficult to accept ‘no’ it becomes very difficult to ‘say’ it as well. People sometimes feel ashamed or guilty if they have to say NO. The corporate culture as such, grooms you to not to say no. Because it might harm your career, so go ahead accept everything with a nod and life is simple. They often do things against their will and end up feeling used and resentful.
The startling point here becomes the ‘unsettling’ idea behind the word itself. The two letters individually do not mean anything to us. Yet together they imply a lot. A “no” says something about the individual and that at times mean we are not good enough.
The unease of negation sometimes paralyzes us. We even fear a “no” so much that we put off, or avoid, certain topics to be discussed because we are not prepared to hear a “no”.
The expression thus seeks assertiveness, resilience and patience. All three we lack when it comes to accepting this word in its true meaning and principle. In India it stares at us and asks “kyun, dar gaya?”
That's like a completely different perspective to a word i use so many times in a day! Now i'll think of this post before saying no… hmmm…interesting 🙂
Whoa wat a post!!
Tu bahut hi sade hue mood main thi na jab yea likha? Kis majnu ne teri na main haan dekhi meri jaan?
But, I agree wit everythin in ur post..loved the way it flowed 🙂
@nim- haha yeah actually i have always thought of this word in this context
@shanu- heheh sadey huye mood mein actually. exams hein na.. itna sada huya mood banta hai. wrote it long time back.. just edited it a bit and posted…
Q. will u start exercising from tomorrow?
A. NO
Q. will u finish this work on time?
A. NO
Q. will u reach there on time?
A. NO
Q. will u think on cutting down on the food?
A. NO
Q. will u be regular with your blog posts?
A. NO
Q. will u ever stop being lazy?
A. NO
Q. will u stop behaving like the IPL is the most important thing in the world nowadays?
A. NO
Q. will u stop staring at her?
A. NO
there…i do say no 2 quite a few things in a normal day…n i stand by them too…strangely its always been pretty easy 4 me! 😀
word of the day: "mantiss"…a praying one or an atheist? 😉
You make a great and known point here.
I was nodding my head solemnly when reading this post, amazed at how much of what you said here I agree with…
Happy that someone somewhere (you), had managed to put all that I agree with, on this topic of "The Indian Tendency To Overlook Other People's No", into one blog post…This should appear as an article tucked in the middle of the Sunday tabloid (the heavy one)..That way I could've read it while sipping at tea, njoying the morning breeze, instead of now while searching for my missing sock…
You rock gal! 🙂
Captcha: blenom?
Q. will u start exercising from tomorrow?
A. Ohh like I already do it a lot. by the way do I need to? (almost everyone who is supposed to exercise never accepts that he/she needs to do it)
Q. Will u finish this work on time?
A. Yes certainly (like people don't risk saying no we wnt complete it on time. unless u are full on on bapu -gandhigiri effect)
Q. will u reach there on time?
A. yes I am usually on time. (dsnt matter if u reach there say an hour late. u know the other person will be late as well)
Q. will u think on cutting down on the food?
A. Ohh come on are you insane. (these questions usually aren't answered with straight yes and no>>)
Q. will u be regular with your blog posts?
A. like when we ask u .. u never say 'NO'. u say i am regular with them.. as regular the ideas are .. you are regular.. the ideas arent..
Q. will u ever stop being lazy?
A. a lazy person will never say he is lazy.. he is just taking things easy. u see euphemisms are always great help.
Q. will u stop behaving like the IPL is the most important thing in the world nowadays?
A. hmmm kuch toh khud bhi soch.. i dnt knw how to defend this one..lolz
Q. will u stop staring at her?
A. I was not staring at her…
Mantiss– idiot i meant the MantisBT- bug tracking system
like i thought you were into software computer and shit.. was just testing.. guess u are more into bugs themselves and not into tracking them. hehehe
@brose- hmm a very known one indeed
@choco- hope u found your sock. And thank you for saying I 'rock'.
and sunday newspaper.. actually this was written way back with an idea to send it as a feature to any magazine.. but … aise pada tha.. so posted it here…glad that u liked it..
Hi Riddhi
Loved the insight presented here on a simple negation…
Never really thought how deep rooted are the implications of this two letter word…
The beginning was very witty…nice little sarcasm dipped servings…
The challenge really seems to be at work…and come to think of it in my own life…I think a simple “no” actually drives me faster to something than perhaps a “yes” would…
Maybe also coz “no” implies someone else’s will ruled over ours…n hence the ego issue all over again?
Great read:-)
@suruchi- good see that is what i meant by 'darr gaya kya' it is like challenging u to dot he undo-able. nice. and great to see u here thanks. welcome aboard. liked your blog. but actually exam time so i am trying not to get distracted. will soon grace everyone with my oh-so-long comments..
@bluntu u don't reply to my 'reply to comments' any more. not fair… huh. yehi thi dosti..
First time on your blog..
Insightful post 🙂
P.S: All the best for your exams
thats some really 'no'ing post riddhi… awesome loved it….
you have achieved something really awesome here… cool yaar
lol…ab tune dosti ko beech me laaya hai toh kuch toh karna hi padega 🙂
i guess u have covered all the points in that 'reply to comment' but u did leave 1 point 4 me…so i'll take care of that!
Q. will u stop behaving like the IPL is the most important thing in the world nowadays?
A. no…coz it IS the most important thing at the moment! 😀
n u are right…i'm into software n computers n all that shit (ahhh don't u make me feel really good about my work!), but have got no clue about the mantis thingy but i do know bugzilla…will that do? 😉
word: "dubom" (an anagram of "dumbo"…ahem ahem)
hahhahah
really enjoyed reading it
kool post
I was going through the post just to find when u r going to write about loverboys, aashiqs.. 😀 :D.. U never cease to amuse me..
"Filtering" is the word verification.. guess u would wish this comment was done so..